How to Support Someone Who's Struggling and What Not to Say

RelationshipsMore
Written By The Mental Health Clinic

"Let me know if you need anything" is the line most of us reach for when someone we care about is falling apart. It is well meant, and it almost never gets used. A person who is barely getting through the day is not going to draft a request and send it to you.

Knowing how to support someone who's struggling is a set of specific skills, not a talent for finding perfect words. It comes down to how you notice, what you ask, when you stay quiet, and whether you come back a few days later. Small differences in wording decide whether the other person feels understood or managed.

At The Mental Health Clinic, we work with people across Alberta, by telephone and video, on both sides of this: the ones struggling, and the partners, parents, friends, and coworkers trying to help without making it worse.

Most of the worry here is the fear of getting it wrong. What helps is simpler and more forgiving than the things people agonize over saying, and what hurts is usually predictable enough to sidestep once you know the pattern.

What Does it Mean to Support Someone Who’s Struggling?

Supporting someone who's struggling means helping them feel understood and less alone with what they are carrying, rather than solving the problem for them. In practice it is three things: noticing without judgement, listening more than advising, and staying in contact over time. What you say matters far less than whether the person walks away feeling heard.

That runs against instinct. When someone we love is in pain, the urge is to do something, and doing usually means offering a fix. The fix is for our discomfort as much as theirs.

Emotional Support vs. Trying to Fix the Problem

There is a reason advice so often falls flat. In motivational interviewing, the clinical approach developed by William Miller and Stephen Rollnick, this is called the righting reflex: the automatic pull to correct what looks wrong in someone else's situation.

Unsolicited advice carries a quiet message underneath it, that the person has not already thought of the obvious, and that their distress is a problem to be managed. Most people who are struggling have run every practical suggestion through their head a hundred times.

Emotional support does something different. It communicates that the person makes sense, that their reaction is understandable given what they are dealing with. In therapy, this is one of the first things we watch for in how families talk to each other, because a household can be full of help and still leave someone feeling completely unseen.

What Kind of Practical Help is Most Useful?

Practical help works best when it is specific and low-key. Research by Niall Bolger and colleagues on what they termed invisible support found that support was most useful when the person on the receiving end barely registered it as support at all. Big, visible gestures of help sometimes made people feel worse, because being helped can carry a sting of failure with it.

The takeaway for daily life is straightforward. Dropping off a meal without a speech, taking their kid for the afternoon, texting "picking up groceries, what's on your list" tends to reach people more than "you have to let me help you." Do the thing quietly. Make it easy to accept and easy to decline.

What Should You Say to Someone Who’s Struggling?

The most useful things you can say are short, plain, and honest. "I'm here." "I'm glad you told me." "That sounds really hard, and I'm not going anywhere." None of these solve anything, and that is the point. They tell the person it is safe to be honest with you, which is the thing that keeps them talking.

One move does more work than any script: reflecting back what you hear. If a friend says they are exhausted and cannot see it getting better, you might answer, "so you're worn down, and right now it's hard to picture things shifting." It feels almost too simple. There is a mechanism behind it.

What Words Help Someone Who’s Struggling, and Why?

Putting feelings into words changes what the brain does with them. In a well-known neuroimaging study, Matthew Lieberman and colleagues found that labelling an emotion reduced activity in the amygdala, the brain region tied to threat and alarm. When you name what someone seems to be feeling and they feel that naming is accurate, it can take a small amount of heat out of the moment.

This is why "you seem really overwhelmed" often settles a person more than "everything's going to be fine." Reassurance skips past the feeling. Accurate naming meets it. You do not have to get it perfect either; guessing wrong ("you sound angry") just invites them to correct you ("not angry, more tired"), and now they are describing their own experience, which is exactly where you want them.

What Should You Say When You Don’t Know What to Say?

Silence is allowed. A lot of people talk too much precisely because a pause feels unbearable, and they end up filling it with advice or reassurance the other person did not ask for. Sitting with someone quietly, or saying "I don't have the right words, but I'm not going anywhere," communicates more than a polished response.

When you do want to help beyond listening, ask before you offer. A simple "do you want help thinking this through, or do you just need to get it off your chest?" hands the choice back to them. People who feel some control over a conversation stay in it longer.

What Should You Not Say to Someone Who’s Struggling?

The most common mistakes are attempts to make the person feel better that quietly tell them their feelings are wrong. This is what Marsha Linehan, who developed Dialectical Behaviour Therapy (DBT), called invalidation: any response that dismisses, minimizes, or corrects someone's internal experience. It rarely comes from a bad place. It still stings.

Watch for the reflexes below. Each one has a kinder version.

"At least" is the big one. "At least you have a job," "at least it wasn't worse," "at least you're healthy." The word almost always precedes a comparison that shrinks the person's pain. Silver linings work the same way; a struggling person hears them as "your feelings are inconvenient, please wrap this up."

Minimizing and comparing come next. "Everyone goes through this," "I was depressed once and I just pushed through," "it could be so much worse." Even when true, these move the focus off the person and onto how they should be coping better. If you have a relevant experience, share it as company ("I've been in a dark place too, it's brutal"), not as a benchmark.

Then there is the pivot to fixing. "Have you tried going for a walk / cutting out caffeine / an app?" Sometimes the right information helps, but leading with solutions before the person feels heard reads as impatience. Solutions are far better received once someone believes you actually understand the problem.

How Do You Help Someone Who Says They’re Fine but Seems to Be Struggling?

"I'm fine" is often a door left slightly open. Someone tests whether you will accept the easy answer or gently push on it. Pushing does not mean interrogating. It means naming what you have noticed, plainly and without accusation.

Try describing the behaviour, not the diagnosis. "You've seemed quieter than usual the last couple of weeks, and you've cancelled a few times. I'm not trying to make a thing of it, I just wanted to check in properly." That gives them something concrete to respond to, and it signals you have been paying attention, which is disarming in itself.

If they still say they are fine, let it sit. You have made it clear the door is open, and pressing harder tends to make people retreat further. A quieter follow-up a few days later ("still thinking about you, no pressure to talk") often does what a single intense conversation cannot.

Struggles that show up as withdrawal frequently sit alongside depression, where reaching out first matters, because the person likely will not.

How Do You Help Someone Who Doesn’t Want Help?

You cannot force someone into support, and trying usually backfires. Adults get to make their own choices, including choices that worry the people around them. What you can do is stay close, keep the door open, and lower the barrier to the first step.

That means resisting the ultimatum. "You need to see someone or I can't keep watching this" might feel like tough love, but it often reads as one more thing the person is failing at.

Softer, repeated invitations tend to work better than a single hard push. "If you ever wanted to talk to someone, I'd help you find a name and even sit with you while you call."

Plant small, specific offers rather than big vague ones. "Want me to come with you to the first appointment?" is easier to say yes to than "you should get therapy." For someone overwhelmed, removing a single logistical hurdle can be the difference between thinking about help and getting it.

Virtual options lower the bar further, since online counselling removes the drive, the waiting room, and the effort of leaving the house.

There is a limit to this, and it is worth naming. If the person is in danger, the rules change, and staying quiet to respect their privacy is no longer the priority. More on that below.

How Do You Support Someone Based on Your Relationship?

The basics stay the same across every relationship: notice, listen, ask, follow up. How you apply them shifts depending on who the person is to you.

How to Support a Struggling Partner Without Becoming Their Therapist

With a partner, the pull is to take their pain on as your job to solve, partly because their mood shapes the whole household. Emotionally Focused Therapy, developed by Sue Johnson and Les Greenberg, points to what most couples need in these moments, which is contact and reassurance rather than solutions. Sitting close, staying steady, and saying "we'll figure this out together" speaks to the attachment system directly.

The trap is slipping into the role of their only support and their unpaid counsellor at once. Resentment builds quietly when one partner carries all of it. Encouraging outside support is not a rejection; it protects the relationship. This is a common theme in couples counselling, where partners learn to be a source of comfort without being the entire treatment plan.

How to Support a Struggling Teenager

Teenagers rarely open up on demand, and the classic parental error is the sit-down interrogation. Pressure tends to close them. Side-by-side conversations, in the car or on a walk, where eye contact is optional, often get further than a face-to-face talk at the kitchen table.

Resist the urge to fix or to lecture about consequences. A teen who feels judged stops sharing, and you lose the information you most need. "That sounds like a lot, do you want my take or do you just want me to listen?" respects the autonomy that adolescence is built around.

Struggles in teens can escalate quickly, so keep the channel open even when they push you away, and take any talk of self-harm seriously rather than assuming it is for attention.

How to Support a Struggling Friend or Coworker

With friends and coworkers, the barrier is often the fear of overstepping. You do not need a close relationship to say "you've seemed off, I'm around if you want to talk." Low-key and consistent beats intense and one-time.

At work there is an added wrinkle: a well-being check can read as performance monitoring if it carries an agenda. Keeping it plainly personal, and off the record, is what separates "how are you doing, really?" by the kettle from feeling managed. Casual proximity lowers the stakes, which is why an offhand moment often gets further than a scheduled sit-down.

What Are the Warning Signs of a Mental Health Crisis, and What Should You Do?

A hard time does not automatically mean someone is in crisis. It tips toward one when a person's distress becomes severe enough that they may not be able to keep themselves safe, get through an ordinary day, or manage without more support than the people around them can give. Signs can include a sudden and marked change in behaviour, severe agitation, deep hopelessness, pulling away from everyone, escalating drinking or drug use, or talking about death or suicide. You do not need to work out exactly what is happening before you take a worrying change seriously.

What Are the Warning Signs That Someone May Be Suicidal?

No single behaviour proves someone is suicidal. The concern comes from a meaningful change in how a person usually is, from a cluster of signs appearing together, and from what they are saying and doing. The Government of Canada's own guidance notes that the factors behind suicide differ from person to person, which is why warning signs can be hard to read.

Pay attention to changes in what someone says, such as:

  • talking about wanting to die, or to disappear

  • saying they are a burden to the people around them

  • saying there is no point, no way out, or no future

  • describing pain or hopelessness that feels unbearable

  • making comments about what will happen after they are gone

  • saying goodbye in a way that feels final or out of character

Pay attention to changes in behaviour too, such as:

  • withdrawing from friends, family, or things they used to enjoy

  • giving away meaningful possessions or putting affairs in order

  • a jump in drinking or drug use

  • taking sudden, uncharacteristic risks

  • clear changes in sleep or appetite

  • sharp shifts in mood, agitation, anger, or anxiety

  • a sudden calm after a long stretch of deep distress

You do not have to decide whether someone is "suicidal enough" to deserve help. Warning signs are not a prediction tool, and you cannot read a person's level of risk from one behaviour on its own. If a meaningful change has caught your attention and something feels wrong, asking directly and helping them find support is the safer move, rather than waiting until you are certain. This aligns with current Canadian guidance, which is clear that no single sign reliably predicts suicide.

What Should You Do if You're Worried Someone May Be Suicidal?

Move through this as a progression rather than a script. The goal is to open the conversation and bring in the right support, not to run your own risk assessment.

  1. Name what you have noticed. Start with the behaviour, gently: "you've seemed really withdrawn lately, and you've stopped doing some of the things you usually enjoy. I'm worried about you."

  2. Ask directly. "Are you thinking about suicide?" A review by Dazzi and colleagues in Psychological Medicine found that asking about suicide did not increase suicidal thoughts, and the Government of Canada statesplainly that asking will not raise the risk and can open an important conversation.

  3. Listen instead of arguing or fixing. If they open up, let them talk. Trying to talk them out of the feeling, or rushing to solutions, tends to shut the conversation down.

  4. If they say no, do not assume all is well. Stay with the concern: "okay. I asked because you've seemed to be having a really hard time. What's been going on?" That keeps the door open without turning you into an assessor.

  5. If they say yes, take it seriously and help them connect with support. You do not need to interrogate them. Offer to help them reach a crisis line or counsellor, and to stay on the line or in the room while they do.

  6. Stay with them when safety is uncertain, if it is safe for you. If you believe they may act, or cannot keep themselves safe, stay while you arrange help, or ask another trusted person to. If staying would put you at risk, get to a safe place and call emergency services.

  7. Do not promise secrecy. Keeping suicidal thoughts entirely between the two of you leaves you holding a responsibility no one person can carry safely. You are not betraying them by bringing in help; you are widening the circle of people keeping them safe.

If someone is thinking about suicide, or you are worried about their safety, you can call or text 9-8-8, the Suicide Crisis Helpline, free, any time, and you can reach it when you areworried about someone else, not only for yourself. In Alberta, the Mental Health Help Line at 1-877-303-2642 is also available 24 hours a day. If there is an immediate plan or immediate danger, call 911.

How Can You Support Someone Without Burning Yourself Out?

Supporting a person through a long, hard stretch has a cost, and pretending otherwise leads to supporter fatigue, resentment, and eventually pulling away from the very person who needs you. You cannot pour from a depleted place indefinitely.

Part of what drains supporters is expecting a faster turnaround than recovery usually offers. Progress tends to be slow and uneven, with good weeks followed by setbacks that are neither your failure nor theirs. Bracing for that from the start keeps you from reading every dip as proof that nothing is working.

Set limits and mean them. It is reasonable to say "I can't talk right now, but I can call you tomorrow morning." Being available around the clock is not sustainable, and it is not more helpful; it teaches the other person to rely on one source rather than building a wider circle. You are one part of their support, not the whole of it.

Watch for the signs that you are running on empty: dread when their name appears on your phone, irritability, your own sleep or mood slipping. Those are cues to widen the circle and, if needed, get your own support.

Learning to steady your own reactions is a skill in its own right, and it is often where emotion regulation work begins for the people doing the caring.

Practical Tools You Can Use in the Next Conversation

These are simple, evidence-informed starting points rather than guaranteed fixes. Each one has a mechanism behind it.

A Five-Step Structure for a Check-In Conversation

Use this when you want to reach out but do not know how to start. It moves from noticing to following up, and it keeps you from jumping to advice before the person feels heard. Walk through the steps in order.

  1. Notice out loud, and be specific. Name one concrete thing you have seen rather than a label. Say "you've been really quiet in the group chat the last couple of weeks," not "you seem depressed." A specific observation is harder to wave off than a general "how are you?", and it shows you have been paying attention, which is disarming on its own.

  2. Ask one open question, then stop talking. Something like "how are you doing with all of it?" works. Then go quiet and stay quiet, even if it feels awkward for five or ten seconds. Most people rush to fill a pause and answer their own question; the other person often says the real thing only after the first polite "I'm fine" has had room to sit.

  3. Reflect what you hear before you respond. Put their feeling into words and offer it back: "so it's been relentless, and you're running on empty." This is the affect-labelling step from earlier, and it does two jobs. It shows them you understood, and if you are slightly off, they will correct you ("not empty, more just numb"), which gets them describing their own experience. Resist adding "but" and a solution here; only reflect.

  4. Ask what they need instead of guessing. People want different things when they are low, and the wrong kind of help can feel like being handled. Ask plainly: "do you want to vent, do you want company, or do you want help thinking through next steps?" Then give them what they asked for, not what you would want in their place.

  5. Circle back a few days later. One conversation is a moment; a second one is support. Send a short, low-pressure note: "been thinking about you since we talked, how's this week been?" You do not need an excuse or an update to check in, and the fact that you remembered usually means more than anything clever you said the first time.

What Should You Do When You Want to Fix Their Problem?

Fixing is the hardest reflex to hold back, so decide your response before you are in the moment. The format is an if-then plan: when you feel the urge to jump in with a solution, then say a version of the lines below instead of the fix.

"I have some thoughts if they'd be useful, but I don't want to skip past what you're dealing with. Do you want me to just listen right now, or do you want ideas?"

This works because it interrupts the righting reflex, the automatic pull to correct what looks wrong, without leaving you silent and useless. It also hands the person a choice, which lowers their guard, since advice someone asked for feels like help while the same advice unasked for feels like criticism.

Then follow their answer. If they want ideas, keep them tentative and brief: "one thing that helped a friend in a similar spot was X, though you know your situation better than I do." If they only want to be heard, drop the advice completely and go back to reflecting. The point is not to withhold your help for good; it is to make sure it arrives after they feel understood, when they can take it in.

How Can You Prepare Yourself Before a Difficult Conversation?

Steady yourself before you start, because the other person will borrow your state. Walk in anxious and urgent and they will feel like a problem being handled; walk in calm and they have something steadier to settle against. Two minutes is enough, and it has two parts.

First, name your goal in one sentence, out loud in the car or quietly in your head: "my job here is to understand, not to fix." Naming the goal keeps you from sliding into problem-solving the second they say something hard, which is the most common way these talks go sideways.

Then slow your breathing for about a minute, making each exhale longer than each inhale. A simple version is to breathe in for a count of four and out for a count of six, six or seven times. The long exhale is the part that shifts your body from alert toward calm, so your voice, face, and pace settle before you say a word.

Can Therapy Help When Someone You Love is Struggling?

Supporting someone through a difficult period can bring up your own anxiety, frustration, guilt, helplessness, or resentment. Therapy gives you somewhere to work through those reactions while learning how to respond to the person you care about without taking responsibility for their recovery.

You might seek counselling because you are struggling to set boundaries, feeling responsible for keeping someone else stable, having repeated arguments with a partner, or finding yourself unsure how to respond when someone withdraws or refuses help. Therapy can also be useful when supporting someone has started affecting your own sleep, mood, relationships, or daily functioning.

At The Mental Health Clinic, our therapists work with individuals, couples, and families across Alberta through telephone and video counselling. Depending on what you are dealing with, therapy may draw from approaches such as CBT, DBT, or Emotionally Focused Therapy.

You do not have to wait until the situation becomes a crisis before getting support yourself.

Common Questions About Supporting Someone Who's Struggling

How Do I Help Someone Who Says They’re Fine?

Talk about what you have noticed rather than telling them how they feel. You might say, “You’ve seemed quieter lately, and I’ve noticed you’ve cancelled a few plans. I wanted to check in.” If they still say they are fine, leave the door open and check in again later rather than pressing them for an explanation.

What Should I Say to Someone Who’s Struggling?

Keep it simple and focus on helping them feel heard. You might say, “I’m here,” “I’m glad you told me,” or “That sounds really hard.” Reflecting what you hear, rather than immediately offering advice or reassurance, can make it easier for them to keep talking.

What Should I Do If Someone Doesn’t Want Help?

Respect their choice while keeping the door open. Instead of repeatedly telling them they need therapy, offer something specific, such as helping them find a therapist or going with them to an appointment. If you believe they are in immediate danger, safety takes priority and professional or emergency support may be needed.

Does Asking About Suicide Put the Idea in Their Head?

No. Asking someone directly about suicide does not cause suicidal thoughts. If you are concerned, asking clearly and calmly can give the person an opportunity to talk about something they may have been afraid to say. If they say they are thinking about suicide, stay with them if it is safe to do so and connect them with appropriate support, such as 9-8-8 or emergency services when there is immediate danger.

How Do I Support Someone Without Burning Myself Out?

Set limits and keep them; being available at every hour is not sustainable and quietly builds resentment. You are one part of someone's support, not their entire treatment plan, so encourage a wider circle and professional help. Watch for dread, irritability, and your own slipping sleep, which are signals to get support of your own.

Remember: supporting someone who is struggling asks less of you than most people fear. It is rarely about the right words; it is about noticing, staying, and coming back, and being honest with yourself about what you can carry.

How can someone in Alberta get help if they won't leave the house?

Virtual therapy has made this far easier, since counselling by telephone or video removes the drive, the waiting room, and the effort of leaving home, which are real barriers when someone is depressed or anxious. Providers across Alberta, including The Mental Health Clinic, offer sessions this way. For urgent support any time, 9-8-8 is available by call or text anywhere in the province.

Educational Disclaimer

This article is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. If you're experiencing mental health concerns that interfere with your daily functioning, please reach out to a qualified mental health professional. If you're in crisis, contact your local crisis line or emergency services immediately.

The Mental Health Clinic
Next

Rejection Sensitivity: Why Small Criticism Feels So Painful and What Can Help